3. Standards

I’ve spent the past few days reviewing the CA state standards for education (slowly becoming the national Common Core Standards).  This is always my first step in preparing for the new school year.  I realize that many homeschoolers want nothing to do with state standards; that’s partly why we homeschool, right?  But, for me, the standards are a natural starting point.  Maybe this is a byproduct of my time as a public school teacher.  My credentialing program taught me to design lesson plans based on the state standards.  Additionally, I was encouraged to write those standards specific to the day’s lesson on the whiteboard so that the students would know why we were studying whatever we were that day.  I’d be shocked to learn, though, that even one student paid any attention to what I wrote.  Kids don’t care about state standards.  Why  would they?  The wording is so convoluted that, often, even adults have to reread them several times to understand the meaning.  From the students’ point of view, standards are just another set of rules they are asked to follow without question.  Writing the standards on the whiteboard might have made my classroom appear more focused and exemplary to visitors and administrators.  But, did it actually serve a useful purpose and benefit the kids?  No.  In fact, I think it might have overwhelmed some of them.  I stopped writing the standards on the whiteboard.

So, why do I still read the standards?  I believe they are worthy goals for teachers.  Granted, it’s very difficult to achieve these standards in a classroom setting with 20-30 students.  With just two students, though, I can do it.  Also, as a teacher and mom who likes to plan, I feel most confident organizing my curriculum around concrete goals.  The standards give me a framework.  In reality, as I read the state standards for each kid’s grade level (which can take a while and be somewhat tedious), I find that Ashby and Ryan are already secure in many of them.  So, I just highlight the ones I want to address in the coming year and build from there.  As the school year progresses, I occasionally review the  highlighted standards to make sure we on track and adjust future lessons accordingly.  This review process takes only a few minutes at a time and gives me a sense of reassurance that we are headed in the right direction.  Of course, I never ask Ashby and Ryan to read the standards; they’re just for me.


5 thoughts on “3. Standards

  1. thehomeschoolmomblog

    I agree; I read the CA standards at the beginning of each school year and then review them after each quarter to make sure we are somewhat on track. They aren’t black and white for me, just a guideline and a point of reference. After all; having a ruler often helps.
    I find it interesting though that when I have asked public school kids if they have learned certain items on the list, they haven’t learned them at all. So, I don’t sweat it.
    It would be one thing, if I made the list mandatory and stressed over it, but it’s another to use it as a guide.
    Great post! 🙂


  2. Therese

    I do this too, Marisa! Then I glance through the EB Hirsch “what every X grader should know” standards. Then I check with my kids about what they want to learn. Then we launch ourselves in a certain direction and see where that year’s journey takes us. The first year, I think I did a review in June and realized that there were very specific minor things that we missed, i.e. “hey, do you know what a title page is?” “No.” “Oh, well, it’s this….” “OK.” NOW we’re on schedule. 🙂

    Love your reflections and your beautiful writing style; thank you for sharing!


    1. Marisa Post author

      Thanks for the comment, Therese. I remember reading Hirsch’s first grade book back when Ashby was in K. But, it’s been a while. I think a trip to the library is in my near future. 🙂



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s